MC Finans All articles
Entrepreneurial Finance

The Advisor Interview: Seven Questions That Separate Fiduciaries from Salespeople

MC Finans
The Advisor Interview: Seven Questions That Separate Fiduciaries from Salespeople

Photo: U.S. Embassy Tel Aviv on Flickr, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Business owners would never hand a stranger control of their company's bank accounts on the strength of a polished pitch. Yet every year, millions of Americans do essentially that with their retirement savings—signing with a financial advisor after a single friendly meeting, without asking a single hard question.

The asymmetry is understandable. Advisors are trained conversationalists; clients often feel they lack the technical vocabulary to probe. But interviewing an advisor is not a technical exercise. It is a hiring decision, and the same questions that reveal character in a job candidate reveal conflicts here. Ask these seven, and listen carefully not just to the answers, but to the evasions.

1. Are you a fiduciary at all times, or only sometimes?

This is the foundational question. A fiduciary is legally obligated to act in your best interest; a suitability standard merely requires that a recommendation be appropriate. Many advisors operate in both capacities depending on the account—fiduciary for fee-based advisory accounts, salesperson for commission-based products. Ask for the answer in writing, and treat hedging as a red flag. 'I always do what's best for my clients' is not a legal standard. 'Yes, in writing, at all times' is.

2. How do you get paid, in total?

The honest answer has several parts: assets under management fees, flat or hourly fees, commissions, and any revenue you generate indirectly. Ask specifically about trailing commissions on products sold years earlier, and about revenue from fund companies for shelf space. An advisor who cannot produce a complete picture of their compensation within a minute is either hiding something or has not examined it—and both are disqualifying.

3. What is the all-in cost of my portfolio?

Advisor fees are only one layer. Underlying fund expense ratios, transaction costs, and the tax consequences of active trading all compound against you. A 1% advisory fee layered on funds averaging 0.9% means your portfolio starts each year roughly 2% in the hole. Ask the candidate to estimate total cost on a hypothetical $500,000 portfolio. Competence shows in a specific number.

4. What products do you sell, and how often do you recommend them?

Some advisors are, functionally, distribution channels for annuities, whole life insurance, or proprietary funds. There is nothing inherently wrong with any of these instruments—but there is something wrong with a 'planner' whose planning always terminates in the same product. Ask what percentage of clients ended up purchasing what, and why.

5. What is your investment philosophy, and how did it perform in 2008 and 2022?

Every advisor sounds brilliant in a bull market. The instructive periods are the drawdowns. Ask how their typical client portfolio behaved in the financial crisis and the 2022 bond-and-stock decline, and what they advised clients to do at the bottom. You are listening for a coherent, repeatable framework—not predictions, and not amnesia.

6. Who is your typical client, and who is not a good fit?

Strong advisors turn business away. If the person across the table claims to serve everyone from recent graduates to retirees with $10 million, they are describing a sales territory, not a practice. A clear niche—business owners nearing a liquidity event, for instance—suggests genuine expertise in circumstances like yours.

7. May I see your Form ADV?

Every registered investment advisor files a Form ADV with the SEC or state regulators, disclosing fees, conflicts, and disciplinary history. Requesting it is standard practice; an advisor who seems irritated by the request has told you something important. Read Part 2, which describes services and conflicts in plain English.

Interpreting the Vague Answer

Three responses should end the interview. 'We get paid by the company'—you are the company, indirectly. 'It's complicated'—fee transparency is a regulatory requirement, not a privilege. And 'Don't worry about that'—worry, immediately.

A legitimate professional will welcome these questions, because a fiduciary with a clean structure competes well on exactly these terms. The interview costs you an hour. Signing with the wrong advisor costs a percentage of everything you own, every year, for decades.

All Articles

Related Articles

Beyond the Base Salary: How to Negotiate a Compensation Package That Actually Builds Wealth

Beyond the Base Salary: How to Negotiate a Compensation Package That Actually Builds Wealth

Earning in One State, Building Wealth in Another: The Remote Worker's Geographic Advantage

Earning in One State, Building Wealth in Another: The Remote Worker's Geographic Advantage

The Slow Erosion: Why Locked-In Spending Habits Become Your Greatest Inflation Vulnerability

The Slow Erosion: Why Locked-In Spending Habits Become Your Greatest Inflation Vulnerability